A sergeant I know told me about his parking lot habit about five months after he got promoted. Shift ended at eleven, and before he drove home he’d sit in his patrol car with the engine running for twenty minutes, sometimes forty, phone face down and the radio off. His wife figured he was finishing paperwork.
I asked him what he was doing out there. He thought about it for a second and said, “Figuring out what I’m going to say about my day.” Then he laughed, because most nights the answer was nothing.
He wasn’t in crisis, and by every metric the job keeps he was doing fine. His shift liked him well enough, his reports were clean, and nobody above him had a complaint. What he’d lost was quieter than any of that. Somewhere in those five months, every place he used to put the day down had disappeared.
If you’ve worn stripes for more than a few months, you might know that car. Before the promotion, that place was easy to find. You finished a bad call and talked it through with your shift mates. You stood around at the end of shift until somebody said the thing everybody was thinking, usually with a joke attached that would never survive an HR review. Nobody called it a wellness program, but it kept a lot of us level for a lot of years.
Then you get promoted, and the people you used to unload with become the people you evaluate. You can still be friendly with them. What you can’t do is tell them you’re not sure you handled their buddy’s complaint right, or that you’re getting leaned on about overtime. So you start editing yourself a little at a time, and it happens so gradually you never notice the day it tipped. A year later, the only person who knows what your week was actually like is you.
Home gets the short version too. Most of us decided a long time ago that our families don’t need the details, and that’s a fair call. The trouble is that “fine,” said every night for a year, starts to work like a closed door, and the people on the other side of it can tell.
Making a decision alone is part of the job. Somebody has to own the call when the shift is short or a family needs bad news, and when it’s you, it’s you. I’m not arguing with that. What I’d push back on is the idea that carrying it alone comes with the stripes. Nobody hands you that part at the promotion ceremony. You pick it up by default, because nobody told you where to help disperse that stress.
Ryan Holiday quotes Seneca in Stillness Is the Key: “There is no enjoying the possession of anything valuable unless one has someone to share it with.” Holiday spends most of that book making the case for solitude, so when he stops to admit it has a limit, I pay attention. Time alone is where you do your thinking, and you were never meant to move in there. For what it’s worth, Seneca made his whole case for self-sufficiency in a long run of letters to a friend. Even the Stoic needed somebody to write to.
I’m better at the first half of that than the second. I ride alone a lot, and I like it. But every time I stop somewhere worth stopping, I take a bad picture and send it to somebody, and I can’t remember ever keeping one to myself. So I already know this. I’ve never bothered to apply it at work.
The fixes I’ve seen work are simple enough to start this week, whether you’ve been supervising five months or fifteen years.
Start by finding one peer outside your building. Same level, a different agency or district, somebody with no stake in your politics, and meet once a month. The first couple of times you’ll talk about scheduling software and who’s retiring. Somewhere around the third coffee, one of you will say the real thing and the other will say “same,” and I’d trade most of the leadership classes I’ve sat through for that one word. If nobody comes to mind, call whoever ran your first supervisor class and ask who else came through with you. Odds are a few of them are sitting in the same parking lot.
At home, try saying one true thing a week. Your spouse doesn’t need the call itself. Tell them the part that stuck with you, or the thing that went right that nobody else noticed. It gives the people who love you a version of your job that isn’t only the worst of it, and it gives you some practice saying something besides “fine.”
If you’re the one promoting people, don’t leave them in the parking lot. The day somebody pins on stripes, introduce them to two other new supervisors and one person who has been in the seat a few years. Then call them at thirty days and ask how they’re doing, not how the shift is doing. They’ll tell you the shift is great. Ask again, and wait a little longer for the answer this time.
Once in a while, take inventory. Write down the people you used to tell things to five years ago, and put a mark next to the ones you’d still call after a bad night. If the marks are thin, treat it the way you’d treat any maintenance item you let slide because it never broke all at once, and get to it before it does.
None of this takes much time: an hour a month, a few minutes at the kitchen table, one phone call. That’s part of why it gets skipped. It doesn’t look like work, nobody will write you up for ignoring it, and you usually find out what it cost later, all at once.
I’ve watched good leaders go a long way on fumes because they believed carrying it alone was part of the job. Some burned out. Others got hard in a way that made them worse at the thing they cared about most. A few retired and realized everyone they’d talked to for twenty years had reported to them, and that turned out to be a different thing from having friends. None of them were weak. Nobody ever told them it was optional.